Charcoal-and-white kitchen with an oak island seating area and a sunny breakfast nook overlooking a late-autumn Michigan yard.

What Hartland's New M-59 Homes Cost Next to the Rest of the Township

Four finished houses on Lockerbie Lane, in Allen Edwin Homes' Highland Reserve community off M-59 near Hartland Glen, are listed at $474,900, $479,900, $489,900 and $499,900. All four have four bedrooms, two and a half baths and a two-car garage, and they range from 1,882 to 2,276 square feet. Through the first ten months of 2026, the median residential sale in Hartland Township was $486,900, according to Realcomp's local market update.

That middle number falls between the second and third prices on Lockerbie Lane. In most markets a buyer pays extra for new construction. In Hartland this fall, a brand-new four-bedroom costs about the same as the township's typical home sale.

The Same Money, Two Different Houses

Here are the asking prices at Highland Reserve as of mid-November, next to Realcomp's figures for Hartland Township:

Figure Amount Period
Highland Reserve floor plans, starting price $433,735 Builder site, mid-November 2026
Highland Reserve quick move-ins $474,900 to $499,900 Builder site, mid-November 2026
Hartland Twp. residential median sale price $486,900 January through October 2026
Hartland Twp. residential average sale price $505,112 January through October 2026
Percent of list price received 100.2% January through October 2026

Realcomp's township median includes every residential sale in Hartland, so it mixes established homes on every kind of lot with whatever new construction closed. At Highland Reserve, the price buys a house that has never been lived in, in a subdivision planned with private paved roads and two cul-de-sacs, as Livingston Daily described it in December 2024. At the same price, the buyer is no longer deciding whether new construction is worth extra money. They are weighing what an established Hartland house and its lot have against a new house in a new subdivision.

Sellers can do the same math. Residential sales in Hartland closed at 100.2% of list price on average from January through October 2026, so homes were holding their asking prices. A seller pricing an established home near $490,000 is competing with a finished four-bedroom on M-59 at the same number. The house needs to show why it is worth the same.

Why the Monthly Median Swings So Much

Read one month of Hartland data and the township seems to change direction every few weeks. Realcomp's residential median was $517,500 for August 2026, $383,800 for September and $461,250 for October. Those months had 16, 15 and 16 closed residential sales.

With only about 16 sales a month, a few unusual closings can move the median a long way. Realcomp's own footnote warns that its percentage changes "can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size." October's median of $461,250 was 15.4% below October 2025's $545,000. Over the full year, though, the township median rose 5.8%, and year-to-date closed sales were essentially flat at 110, compared with 111 a year earlier. The year-to-date figure is the one to compare against a builder's price sheet. We made the same argument about Lake Fenton's headline median, and it holds even more strongly in a township this size.

Most of the Fully Approved Homes on This Stretch Are Rentals

The new housing is clustered on the east side of the township along M-59, known locally as Highland Road. Planning Director Troy Langer told Livingston Daily in late 2024 that this side of Hartland would likely see hundreds of new homes in the coming years. He also said the township was not the one seeking them out. Here is how the township's records list each project:

Project Location Homes Type Township status
Redwood Hartland, Phase I Off E. Highland Rd. near Hartland Glen 148 Single-story rentals Built and leasing
Redwood Hartland, Phase II Redwood Rose Way 130 in 28 buildings Single-story rentals Final approval May 20, 2025
Highland Reserve M-59 at Hartland Glen 108 71 for sale as site condominiums, 37 rentals Amendment approved Aug. 5, 2025
Sawyer Ridge M-59 at Pleasant Valley 158 to 172 Detached single-family Preliminary approval July 15, 2025
Square One SW corner of M-59 and Old US-23 About 168 apartments plus commercial Apartments Preliminary review listed as under review

Add up the projects that are built or have final approval. Redwood's two phases and the rental share of Highland Reserve come to 315 rental homes. The for-sale side has 71 site condominiums at Highland Reserve. Sawyer Ridge would change that balance. WHMI connected the project's applicant, David Straub, to M/I Homes. The township's 2025 planning report recorded it at 158 homes, and its current project page lists 172 detached homes with preliminary approval. Square One would add apartments at the township's busiest corner. WHMI reported that its developers wanted a traffic signal on M-59 opposite Target, which MDOT had not committed to.

For a buyer who wants new construction in Hartland today, the 71 sale homes at Highland Reserve are a small supply, and about one home in three in that subdivision is a rental. Plan sizes there ran from roughly 1,600 to 2,400 square feet when the project was described in 2024. The builder now markets both ranch and two-story designs.

The rental option has also gotten more expensive. In December 2024, Livingston Daily reported Redwood's rates at around $1,899 a month. Redwood Hartland now lists starting rent at $2,067 a month for a two-bedroom, two-bath, single-story home with an attached two-car garage. A household that is weighing renting on M-59 for a year before buying in Hartland is looking at more than $24,000 a year in rent at today's starting price.

Where the Condo Numbers Moved

Highland Reserve's for-sale homes are detached houses, but the township approved them as site condominiums. The timing of that approval lines up with a change in Hartland's condo statistics this year. Realcomp's condo category for the township shows 47 closed sales from January through October 2026, compared with 24 in the same period of 2025. The median condo price rose 37.4%, from $301,500 to $414,190.

A median that jumps 37% in a year usually reflects a change in what sold, not a change in what a given condo is worth. One plausible reading is that new detached site condos priced in the $430,000s and up are now included in the condo numbers. A downsizer comparing Hartland's condo median with other towns may be comparing new houses against older attached units. Average days on market for condos also rose year to date, from 58 to 96, and October condo inventory was 20 units, or 3.9 months of supply. Condo buyers in Hartland have more time to decide than house buyers do.

Hartland Is Tighter Than Livingston County Overall

Across Livingston County, inventory is rising. Realcomp's October 2026 county figures show 637 homes for sale, up from 511 in October 2025, with a median sale price of $409,900. In September 2026, county inventory reached 612, which Realcomp marked as a five-year high.

Hartland's residential inventory rose far less. The township had 24 homes for sale in October 2026, compared with 23 a year earlier, and months of supply held at 2.2 in both years. The pace did slow slightly. Year-to-date days on market rose from 23 to 29. That gives buyers about another week to decide, not a market where they can wait out sellers. The extra county inventory is mostly in other communities. In Hartland, the new building on M-59 is where most of the added choice is, and much of it is for rent.

There is more growth ahead. A regional sewer rate study dated October 2025 projected 582 additional Hartland residential equivalent units for fiscal years 2026 through 2030. That is a forecast used for planning, not a list of approved homes. It does show that the east side of the township is expected to keep growing for years. For more on how the township is connecting its older and newer areas, see our piece on the hARTland Art Walk and the sidewalk network, or browse our Hartland neighborhood page.

Quick Answers

Is new construction in Hartland priced above the township's typical sale right now? Not by much at the middle of the market. Highland Reserve's finished homes listed at $474,900 to $499,900 in mid-November 2026, and Hartland's residential median from January through October 2026 was $486,900.

Are Sawyer Ridge homes for sale yet? The township's current project page lists Sawyer Ridge with preliminary planned-development approval from July 15, 2025, for 172 detached homes. Check the township's project page for its current status.

Why did Hartland's condo prices jump this year? The year-to-date condo median rose from $301,500 to $414,190 while condo sales nearly doubled. The mix of what sold changed, and that mix likely includes new detached site condos.

If you are deciding between a finished home on Lockerbie Lane and an established home at the same price somewhere else in Hartland, The Shane Adams Group can compare the two houses side by side, covering lot, condition, setting and resale prospects. If you own a home in Hartland and want to know how it holds up against new construction at your price, start with a home valuation and then contact us.

Work With Us

Partner with Shane Adams Group for trusted guidance and exceptional service throughout your real estate journey. We are committed to helping buyers and sellers achieve their goals with confidence and ease.

Follow Me on Instagram